Everton’s Disappointing Start at Elland Road
Everton needed a positive result—either a draw or a win—along with a strong performance to set the tone for David Moyes’ first full season back in charge. However, Leeds United spoiled their plans with a controversial late penalty from debutant Lukas Nmecha, sealing a 1-0 victory and leaving Moyes frustrated after a dismal first-half display from his side.
For the second consecutive season, the Toffees began their campaign without Jarrad Branthwaite, whose physical presence was sorely missed as Leeds dominated defensively.
Branthwaite’s Absence Felt
Everton are a far better side with Branthwaite in the lineup. The England international brings power and composure, forming a solid partnership with James Tarkowski. But a hamstring injury ruled him out, and he could remain sidelined for several more weeks.
His absence was particularly evident in the first half, where Everton struggled defensively. While there were some encouraging signs—winning 51% of duels and 81% of their tackles (compared to Leeds’ 53%)—the lack of defensive solidity was clear. Michael Keane put in a decent shift, proving he can deputize when needed, but the backline still looked vulnerable.
Jake O’Brien Exposes Everton’s Right-Back Problem
Jake O’Brien, signed from Lyon for £17m last summer, flourished under Moyes, starting 17 of the final 19 league games last season. With Ashley Young gone and Nathan Patterson injured again, the right-back spot is his for now—unless Everton make a late signing.
While O’Brien is a tenacious defender, his attacking limitations were exposed against Leeds. He completed just 12 of 27 passes, lost possession 27 times, and failed to create a single chance. Sofascore’s data highlighted his struggles:
- 0 key passes
- 1/8 long balls completed
- 7/14 duels won
The Liverpool Echo gave him a 6/10, noting he kept Wilfried Gnonto quiet, but he was still the weak link in a defense that conceded from Tarkowski’s controversial handball.
Everton Must Strengthen in Defense
Leeds recorded the highest xG (2.28) of any Premier League team in Matchweek 1—a worrying stat for Everton’s backline. O’Brien is a capable defender, but the Toffees need a more dynamic right-back who can contribute in attack.
Recent links to Manchester City’s Rico Lewis suggest Everton recognize the issue. If The Friedkin Group fails to sign an upgrade, it could prove costly. Leeds’ victory highlighted exactly why Everton must act before the transfer window closes.
